Anglin Says Government Is Negotiating to Buy Another School

9 min read

Updated

The Speaker, the Premier, the Principal and the Education Minister at the opening of the Birch Tree Hill Campus
From left Premier André Ebanks MP, Principal Jovanna Wright and Education Minister Rolston Anglin MP at the official opening of the Sir John A. Cumber Primary School Birch Tree Hill Campus in West Bay on 16 November

The Government is negotiating to buy another school, the Minister for Education and Training, Rolston Anglin MP, said on 16 November at the official opening of the West Bay campus it bought in July for CI$6.5 million. "The word is out that we're negotiating for another school and negotiate we shall," he said. "We must acquire the requisite school spaces for a growing population." He did not name the school.

Mr Anglin MP, who is also Minister for Finance and Economic Development, used the ceremony to defend the West Bay purchase, which falls within an audit by the Office of the Auditor General. Welcoming Kenneth Bryan MP, the Deputy Leader of the Opposition, from the podium, he said: "Thank you, sir, for coming out and seeing this great facility that a little storm in a teacup developed, shall we say."

The campus is the former Kiddiewinks preschool at 61 Birch Tree Hill Road, bought by the Government in July for CI$6.5 million and now the Birch Tree Hill Campus of Sir John A. Cumber Primary School. The Caymanian Journal (TCJ) reported on 24 October that two of the three valuations obtained for the Government put the site at CI$5 million or less, and that one of the two sellers had nominated the Premier, André Ebanks MP, for election in 2025.

"A little storm in a teacup"

Mr Anglin MP used his speech to defend the decision to buy an existing building. "You see, there are some in the community who have decided that they think that you can just slap a building together and we could just buy it as government," he said. "This was a purpose-built facility by operators who have a school in town in George Town that is really excellent."

The Minister said West Bay was the fastest-growing district and asked what the alternative had been. "What was I going to do? Wait until we were bursting at the seams and we had to continue to place West Bayers out of catchment?" he said. He then offered an analogy: "It is those who set fire to the fire station and burn it down that turn right around and complain of what government is doing about it and why government didn't out the fire. We averted the fire before it happened." He did not say whom he meant.

He described himself as a Minister "supported by Cabinet colleagues who never gave one bit of hesitation when this was brought to them as a critical key investment in our children". Recalling the first time he walked through the building, he said: "We had to hide our enthusiasm to make sure that the operators didn't see how eager we were."

The Premier attended and did not speak. Mr Anglin MP closed by inviting guests to tour the building. He said he wanted to reach the ribbon-cutting "so that we can see and ensure that everybody sees what there has been much to do about".

What the Opposition has said

Four days after TCJ's 24 October report, the Official Opposition said its leader, Joey Hew MP, had written to the Governor "requesting that the circumstances surrounding the acquisition of the KiddieWinks Preschool be appropriately investigated". The statement added that raising its concerns "does not constitute an allegation or finding of wrongdoing against any individual".

In a recorded statement on 30 October, Mr Hew MP said: "Questions surrounding the Government's purchase of the former Kiddiewinks property are very serious, and the Caymanian people deserve answers." The Governor said on 2 November that she was satisfied there had been no breach of the Ministerial Code of Conduct by the Premier.

Mr Hew MP wrote to the Governor again on 3 November, in a letter his office released to the media the next day, asking for her support in "facilitating the release of the Attorney General's complete opinion on this matter". The same letter said the purchase "has brought to light apparent divisions within the Government, raising concerns about its unity and stability".

The Opposition's statements have concerned the valuation and approval of the purchase and the handling of any conflict of interest. None of them has objected to the school's use of the building.

Mr Bryan MP, who represents George Town Central, was the only Opposition member TCJ saw at the ceremony. His attendance is not evidence of a difference with his leader over how the building was bought. TCJ's reporter heard the Minister ask for him at the ribbon-cutting before a colleague remarked: "I see he left already."

More purchases if buildings can be found

He said he would repeat the West Bay approach elsewhere if comparable buildings were available. "I wish I could find two more of these between Red Bay, Savannah and the Prospect Primary School," he said, adding of North Side and East End: "I'd buy it tomorrow." He committed to capital works in North Side, East End and West End, and said: "I cannot leave office without ensuring that the Lighthouse School expansion is brought to fruition."

He tied the pressure on school places to population growth. "We have granted more than 12,000 statuses in the last decade," he said, adding that the permanent population had risen "in the last 15 years from 57,000 to 90,000". The Economics and Statistics Office estimated the population at 90,832 in June 2026; the 2010 census counted 55,456.

What the school said

The Principal, Jovanna Wright, said the school "proudly welcomed over 85 students to this new campus" in August. She said the campus allows the school "to strengthen our reception provision and expand our support for students with special needs, including our autistic learners".

Julie Hunter MP, a Parliamentary Secretary, said both campuses of the school are in her constituency. "I well remember the parents of autistic children who were so upset and had so much trepidation and came to me before the advent of Kiddiewinks, thinking that their children would have to be placed at the Lighthouse School because of lack of space at the Sir John A. Cumber main campus, and how they were reassured when this facility was opened," she said.

Mr Anglin MP said the school "can now have three ASD classes", referring to autism spectrum disorder. Addressing the Principal, he said: "I know you and your team have been stretched to have a split facility, something that is not ideal. But you know what? Change creates opportunity."

The purchase so far

The Ministry told TCJ in writing on 19 and 21 October that the Lands and Survey Department obtained three valuations of the site: CI$6,895,000 from JEC Property Consultants, CI$4,859,000 from DDL Studio and CI$5,000,000 from BCQS International. The Ministry said the sellers had asked CI$7 million and that it believed it had "achieved good value-for-money with this acquisition".

The Office of the Auditor General told TCJ on 28 October that the transaction "falls within the scope of the audit of the Ministry of Education and Training's 2026 financial statements, which is currently underway". The Commission for Standards in Public Life told TCJ on 29 October that it would continue to monitor the matter.

What no public body has addressed

Unjustified high prices are among the indicators of possible bribery in public procurement listed by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Paying over the odds is among the methods by which public funds have been diverted to private or political ends elsewhere, according to reports by the OECD and the Financial Action Task Force. The OECD said in 2007 that procurement "is certainly a means by which political parties divert public funds illegally to finance themselves", and a 2012 FATF report describes a case in which a contractor was "awarded the contract for an inflated price" and returned part of the money to a politician. Neither body sets a test based on a price exceeding an independent valuation, and the cases they describe concern contracts with suppliers, not the purchase of land or buildings.

Cayman promotes its compliance with both standard setters. The FATF removed the jurisdiction from its grey list in October 2023, a decision the Government said showed its anti-money laundering regime met the global standard. The Attorney General, Samuel Bulgin KC, chaired the Anti-Money Laundering Steering Group, which oversees that regime, until an amendment to the Proceeds of Crime Act in May 2026 gave the chair to the Minister responsible for financial services or a designate. He remains a member. It is his opinion on the West Bay purchase that the Opposition has asked to see in full.

Under that regime, Cayman's banks, law firms and estate agents must apply enhanced due diligence to business involving politically exposed persons, and further checks to their family members and close associates. The regulations define such a person to include anyone "entrusted domestically with prominent public functions" and give "senior executives of a state owned corporation" as an example. The list is illustrative, and it does not name the chair of a statutory authority.

The seller who nominated the Premier chairs the board of the Maritime Authority of the Cayman Islands, a statutory authority. A notice in the Cayman Islands Gazette records that Cabinet appointed her chair for a three-year term from 1 September 2025 to 31 August 2028, and Cabinet's published summary of its meeting of 10 September 2025 lists the appointment. She had been a director of the Authority since 15 November 2022, according to its 2025 annual report. The FATF gives senior executives of state-owned corporations as an example of a politically exposed person, and the United Kingdom's regulations extend the term to "members of the administrative, management or supervisory bodies of State-owned enterprises".

TCJ has seen no evidence that public money was diverted in the West Bay purchase, and no public body has alleged it. The price was below the highest of the three valuations and CI$1.5 million or more above the other two.

The Office of the Auditor General says in its 2025 annual report that it conducts its financial audit work "in accordance with International Standards on Auditing". Those standards require an auditor to assess the risk of fraud and to weigh the business rationale of significant transactions that are unusual or fall outside an entity's normal business. Where such a transaction involves a related party, the standards treat it as a significant risk, and any claim that it was struck at arm's length must be supported by evidence.

Those standards have limits. An audit of financial statements gives an opinion on whether the accounts are fairly stated. A building is recorded at the price paid, so a high price is not in itself an error in the accounts. Under the accounting standard the Government uses, related parties are ministers, senior officials, their close family and entities they control; a person who nominates a candidate for election is not on that list. Whether a purchase was good value is a question for a value-for-money audit, a separate power the Auditor General holds under section 60 of the Public Management and Finance Act. The Office has not said which of these tests it will apply to the West Bay purchase.

No public body has said whether that valuation difference has been examined. The Governor's statements of 2 and 4 November addressed the Ministerial Code of Conduct and the Premier. The second said she had considered that "negotiations were conducted by the Lands and Survey Department through the Chief Valuations Officer, following the standard process used for government property acquisitions"; neither statement mentions the price or the valuations. The Attorney General's complete opinion has not been released. The Auditor General has confirmed only that the transaction falls within an audit now underway. The Governor said on 4 November that the information she considered "did not identify a wider financial, family, business or other material association" between the Premier and the seller. Her statement does not mention the seller's appointment to the Maritime Authority's board.

Published November 18, 2026, 9:00 PM

Join the discussion — please keep to our Community Guidelines.