In Cayman's Domestic Banking, One Player Can Tilt the Table

7 min read
Black lettering reading Elgin Ave on a white wall in George Town, Grand Cayman
Elgin Avenue in George Town is home to the Cayman Islands Government and to much of the financial and legal sector of the Cayman Islands

In a retail banking market of 11 institutions, the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority (CIMA) attributes a fall in the whole sector's capital ratio primarily to one bank's dividend. It is also reviewing a deal whose buyer says it would hold the number one banking position in the Cayman Islands. Both point to the same feature of Cayman's domestic banking, which is how few institutions it takes to move the system's numbers.

CIMA's 2025 Annual Report records the ratio of regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets across the Category A retail banks falling from 34.9% at the end of 2024 to 30.9% at the end of 2025 (p. 32). "The reduction in capital ratios was primarily attributable to one entity that made a significant dividend payment as part of a strategic change in its business model, resulting in a reduction of regulatory capital," the report says (p. 32). In written answers to questions The Caymanian Journal (TCJ) emailed on 6 November 2026, CIMA said the correct year-end 2025 figure is 28.1%, as published in its Financial Stability Report on 14 October 2026. The difference, it said, is "due to subsequent resubmissions of the Quarterly Prudential Returns, during which risk-weighted assets were recalculated". CIMA also said the dividend "was subject to CIMA's prior non-objection".

Profits are explained the same way. "The sector reported a decline in profits, mainly driven by a fair value loss at one bank, which is considered an isolated event, and a reduction in interest income at another bank following the sale of investments to affiliates," the report says (p. 32). Return on equity fell from 21.6% to 15.2% and return on assets from 3.2% to 2.4% (Table 4, p. 32). CIMA told TCJ that Table 4 "has since been updated to reflect the most accurate data during the reporting period".

A market of eleven

CIMA supervised 11 Category A retail banks and 66 Category B banks at the end of 2025 (Table 2, p. 26). The soundness indicators describe the retail tier, where Caymanian households and businesses keep their money. The Financial Stability Report puts the retail banks' deposit base at around US$12 billion and says deposits make up about 96% of their funding. "At the institutional level, concentration in loans and deposits across Category A Retail Banks remains meaningful, reflecting the relatively small number of institutions in the sector," it says, adding that "concentration has not increased over the review period".

The report does not name the banks behind the dividend or the fair value loss, and TCJ is not identifying them. CIMA's May 2025 Regulatory Policy on Domestic Systemically Important Deposit Taking Institutions says the Authority "will not be publishing a list of D-SIDTIs until there is further guidance on the international approach in this regard" (para. 6.8). CIMA told TCJ it "does not intend to publish the list of designated DSIDTIs at this time".

CIMA's reading is that the movements are contained. "Notwithstanding these movements, the CAR remained above the minimum required level, indicating that the sector remains well capitalised," the Annual Report says (p. 32). The Financial Stability Report gives a regulatory minimum of 10% to 15% for the banking sector and says the retail banks' ratio "remains broadly in line with historical norms and continues to reflect a resilient capital base across the sector". Capital, it says, "would continue to serve as the primary shock absorber in the event of external stress". Non-performing loans stayed at 1.6% of gross loans, which CIMA says ranked second lowest among Bermuda, the Bahamas, Barbados, Trinidad and Tobago, the British Virgin Islands and Jamaica at the end of 2024 (p. 32).

The deal under review

"Recent publicly announced consolidation developments involving regional banking groups could, if completed, affect concentration within the domestic retail banking sector, including the distribution of deposits, loans and payment-service relationships across Category A Retail Banks," the Financial Stability Report says. CIMA told TCJ the passage "refers to Butterfield's proposal to acquire control of CIBC Caribbean, which remains under CIMA's review". On 28 May 2026 Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son Limited announced an agreement to acquire CIBC's 91.7% interest in CIBC Caribbean Bank Limited for US$1.794 billion. Both groups have retail banking operations in the Cayman Islands.

Butterfield has told its own shareholders what the deal would mean for market position. "Together with CIBC Caribbean, we will hold the number one banking position in the Cayman Islands, Bermuda, Barbados, The Bahamas, and Turks & Caicos," Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Michael Collins wrote in the letter accompanying the notice of the bank's annual general meeting, dated 14 August 2026. The letter gives no market share figure for the Cayman Islands. In Butterfield's third quarter results on 27 October 2026, Mr Collins said shareholders had supported the transaction "by strongly voting in favor of the issuance of Butterfield shares", and added: "We continue to expect closing in the first half of 2027."

Answering a question in Parliament on 24 June 2026, Premier and Minister for Financial Services and Commerce André Ebanks MP said CIMA would assess any application "in accordance with its statutory mandate, including whether the proposed transaction gives rise to any undue risk to the public interest, the financial system, or the reputation of the country". In a response to TCJ on 10 November 2026, the Ministry of Financial Services and Commerce said: "There has been no engagement between the Ministry and Butterfield, as the proposed acquisition involving CIBC Caribbean and Butterfield is a regulatory matter for CIMA."

The plan if a bank fails

The Cayman Islands has no deposit insurance scheme and no bank resolution law, and the question is not new. "There is no deposit insurance fund," the International Monetary Fund said in its 2009 assessment of financial supervision in the Cayman Islands, adding that, given the size of bank deposit liabilities relative to the economy, "there is no compelling argument to establish one with universal participation". In March 2025 CIMA hosted an IMF technical assistance mission on a recovery and resolution regime for deposit-taking institutions, and the Annual Report says that in October 2025 it received the IMF's final report, "which included recommendations and a roadmap to strengthen the jurisdiction's financial crisis preparedness and supervisory resilience" (p. 68). CIMA told TCJ its most recent IMF mission took place in September 2026 and that the report from it is not yet public.

Recovery planning, which requires banks to plan their own rescue, is within CIMA's powers. CIMA told TCJ the Rule and Statement of Guidance on Recovery Planning was gazetted on 7 October 2026 and takes effect on 7 October 2027 after a 12-month transition period. Resolution needs legislation, and CIMA said it "has submitted its recommendations for legislative reform on resolution planning to the Ministry of Financial Services".

TCJ emailed the Ministry on 6 November 2026 asking when a bill would come to Parliament, whether a deposit guarantee is under consideration and whether the IMF report will be published. "The Ministry has received CIMA's recommendations and the October 2025 IMF technical assistance report. Because both are in review, further comment will be made in due time," it said on 10 November 2026. No figure has been published for what a resolution regime would cost to run, or for what a retail bank failure would cost the public purse without one. CIMA said the cost of hosting the IMF mission can be requested under its Freedom of Information process.

CIMA's Acting Chief Executive Officer Patrick Bodden said on 14 October 2026 that "the strength of the Cayman Islands' financial system continues to be underpinned by strong prudential standards, sound capital and liquidity positions and a robust regulatory and supervisory framework". He added that "the increasingly interconnected nature of global finance requires continued vigilance and a forward-looking approach to identifying emerging vulnerabilities".

A capital ratio of 28.1% sits well above the 10% to 15% regulatory minimum the Financial Stability Report gives for the banking sector. What the regulator's own explanations describe is not a weak system but a narrow one, in which one board's decision can become everyone's number. CIMA's report says the consolidation now under its review could, if completed, affect that concentration.

Published November 18, 2026, 9:32 PM

Join the discussion — please keep to our Community Guidelines.