Conservation Bodies Oppose Bill That Would Remove Legal Basis for Cat Cull

7 min read
A black and white cat looks out through rusted metal bars with one paw against the bars
A petition and Cayman's conservation bodies oppose a bill that a U.S. cat charity wants MPs to pass

A bill that would take cats outside the law used to cull them on Little Cayman and Cayman Brac is opposed by the National Conservation Council (NCC), the National Trust for the Cayman Islands and a public petition that passed 300 signatures on Friday, 20 November. The bill's supporters include a U.S. cat charity, which wants the killing of feral cats stopped. Parliament rose on Friday evening until 11 December without reading it.

The National Conservation (Amendment) Bill, 2026, sponsored by Christopher Saunders MP, the independent opposition member for Bodden Town West, would rewrite the definition of "alien species" in the National Conservation Act so that any species present in the islands for 100 years no longer counts as alien. That definition underpins the Department of Environment's (DoE) programme to trap and kill unowned cats in environmentally sensitive areas of Little Cayman and Cayman Brac, where the NCC says cats kill hatchlings of the Sister Islands rock iguana, a species found nowhere else. The National Trust says the change would also take rats, logwood and other introduced plants and animals outside the Act's reach.

The two sides therefore line up as follows. Those who want the cull to end support the bill. Those who want the Act left as it is, including the petition's signatories, oppose the bill, and the petition is not a petition to protect cats.

The bill was listed under Other Business on the Order Papers for Thursday, 19 November and Friday, 20 November, for first reading through to third reading. It was not reached on either day, and Parliament adjourned on Friday evening until 10:00 on Friday, 11 December. The petition against it, started on change.org on 17 November under the name Paws off The National Conservation Act, had more than 300 signatures by Friday afternoon against a stated goal of 500, and the National Trust's Youth Advisory Committee added its own call on Friday for MPs to reject the bill. A U.S. cat charity, Alley Cat Allies, urged MPs on 16 November to pass it.

The NCC, on 21 September 2026, and the National Trust, on 30 September 2026, each issued statements opposing the bill. The NCC said the redefinition "is not only at odds with the globally accepted scientific understanding of the term but would also undermine current laws and very quickly unravel decades of dedicated conservation work". The issue has been live since Katherine Ebanks-Wilks MP, Minister for Health, Environment and Sustainability, told Parliament on 1 October that the DoE would be directed to stop shooting trapped feral cats at the point of capture, after Saunders agreed to defer the bill. The bill was listed again on 5 October and that meeting ended without it being read.

What the bill says

The bill was gazetted on 2 September 2026 as Supplement No. 2 to Extraordinary Gazette No. 63. Clause 2 repeals the definition of "alien species" in the National Conservation Act (2013 Revision) and replaces it with "a species whose natural range for the preceding 100 year period does not include the Islands or, with reference to a specific Island, does not include that Island". Clause 3 would bar the NCC from delegating its powers unless it "has received specific written consent of the Cabinet", and would let Cabinet "revoke its consent and direct the Council to revoke any delegated powers as it sees fit". The Act would come into force on a date set by Cabinet.

The bill's memorandum of objects and reasons does not mention cats. It describes the measure as "confirming Cabinet's constitutional executive authority".

The National Trust said: "If the Bill were to pass, cats, rats, logwood and other introduced animals and plants would automatically fall outside the Act's alien species provisions, thus undermining the legal basis for programmes that protect critically endangered wildlife endemic and essential to the Cayman Islands." The NCC said: "Our endemic Blue and Rock iguana hatchlings do not recognise a cat as a threat until it is too late because they are not born with this instinct."

Who decides

Clause 3 reaches beyond cats, to the question of who has the last word on how the Council's powers are used. On that clause, the National Trust said the Act's delegation framework "is the backbone of the efficient functioning of the NCC and its ability to effectively carry out its statutory mandate". The Trust sits on the NCC.

The NCC and the National Trust, part of the network of experts, officials and advocacy groups that The Caymanian Journal (TCJ) refers to as the Blue Iguana class, say the bill would weaken conservation law, and the NCC warned that it would "very quickly unravel decades of dedicated conservation work". The bill's memorandum describes the measure as "confirming Cabinet's constitutional executive authority", and clause 3 would rest the Council's delegated powers on Cabinet's consent.

The petition against the bill

The petition is titled "Paws off the National Conservation Act. Don't be fooled. This bill isn't just about cats!" Its target is the bill, not the cull. It says the public "won't let our only environmental protection law be eroded" and recalls that in January 2025, after residents wrote to MPs and organisations including the National Trust spoke out, the government withdrew its own bill to amend the Act. It describes the Saunders bill as being "presented as protecting cats".

The Youth Advisory Committee's statement, published on gov.ky on 20 November, said the Sister Islands rock iguana population had grown "from around 1,000 to around 3,500 in 2025" since feral cat control began in 2022, and that Little Cayman had reached "100% registration of pet cats". It said animal welfare "should be addressed on its own merits, not used to change how our environment is governed".

What the bill's supporters say

Alley Cat Allies, an advocacy group based in Bethesda, Maryland, said the bill would remove the basis for treating cats as a species that can be culled, because cats have been in the islands for more than 100 years. Coryn Julien, its program communications officer, said in the release: "For years, Alley Cat Allies has condemned the Cayman Islands' cruel and futile slaughter of cats, which includes executing cats by gunshot and poisoning. The killing must stop entirely, and evidence-based humane approaches must be implemented."

The group said removing cats fails because others move in, which it calls the "Vacuum Effect", and that the government "never seriously attempted to implement" trap-neuter-return before turning to lethal control. It said it has worked with advocates in Cayman since 2023 and has provided veterinary services to "hundreds of cats". The release gave no figures for how many cats or at what cost, and named no Cayman organisation.

The release said Parliament "deferred discussion on the bill on October 5". The Minister's statement is dated 1 October on parliament.ky.

The shooting halt

In her statement, Ebanks-Wilks said: "I hereby publicly give an undertaking to the Member that in the meantime the Government shall direct Department of Environment to discontinue the current practice of shooting trapped feral cats at the site of capture in Little Cayman and other environmentally sensitive areas on Cayman Brac." She said the two sides would "work together to find a suitable balance that will hopefully result in quelling the harm feral cats pose to our precious biodiversity and natural environment in a mutually agreed manner".

Alley Cat Allies said the Minister "cited concerns from the public" when she announced the halt. Ebanks-Wilks said that after consultation with Saunders she had "a greater understanding of the Member's main concern (which is reflective of representations made to him by concerned members of the public) regarding the present predominant method of trapping feral cats and euthanising them by administering a gunshot at the point of capture".

The undertaking covered shooting only. Julien said: "Though shooting was called off for the moment, poisoning was conspicuously left on the table." The NCC approved updated procedures for controlling feral cats in environmentally sensitive areas on 17 September 2025. Neither the NCC's statement nor the National Trust's refers to poison, and the Minister's statement dealt with shooting.

What happens next

Parliament is due to sit again at 10:00 on Friday, 11 December. If the bill passes second reading it goes to committee stage and a third reading, and becomes law only once the Governor has assented to it. Elgin Avenue has published no position on the bill itself: no government statement on it appears on gov.ky, and the statement by the Minister for Health, Environment and Sustainability on 1 October dealt with the shooting halt and the deferral. The NCC has asked MPs to keep the current definition in the Act, and the National Trust has urged "Members of Parliament on both sides of the House to reject" the bill.

Published November 21, 2026, 6:44 PM

Join the discussion — please keep to our Community Guidelines.