Cayman Brac Rents Escalating, MPs Told

6 min read
Yvette Dilbert giving evidence to the Public Accounts Committee
Sister Islands housing corporation chair Yvette Dilbert at the Public Accounts Committee, 4 November — Photo: Courtesy of CIG

Rents in Cayman Brac have climbed so far since the pandemic that they are nearing Grand Cayman levels, the chair of the Sister Islands Affordable Housing Development Corporation (SIAHDC) has told Parliament's Public Accounts Committee (PAC). Yvette Dilbert also told MPs that the homes her board sells for CI$160,000 are out of reach for many people on Brac salaries.

Dilbert gave evidence on 4 November 2026, the first of two days of sittings on the Auditor General's report, The Government's approach to improving access to affordable housing, published on 31 August 2026. She was the final witness of the day and appeared alongside Nicola Anderson-Wildman, chief financial officer for the Ministry of District Administration and Home Affairs and the SIAHDC.

'Almost on par'

The exchange on rents came as a committee member asked whether Cayman Brac would accept multi-storey housing as a cheaper alternative to the single-family homes the corporation builds. Dilbert said she thought it would, and that the choice for many households lay between a less expensive unit in a shared building, a costlier stand-alone home, or continuing "to pay the high rent". She then told the committee: "I will say that since Covid the rental market in Cayman Brac has escalated significantly."

Asked whether she had compared the Brac market with Grand Cayman, Dilbert said: "We're probably kind of getting almost on par. Sounds strange to say for Cayman Brac, but yes, homes that were rented pre-Covid for $600 per month are now $1,200 per month." She offered the figures as an example from the market and did not present them as a survey finding. The Economics and Statistics Office's Labour Force Survey Report Fall 2025, a sample survey dated March 2026, put the mean rent paid in the Sister Islands at CI$727.67 a month and the median at CI$600, against CI$1,627.01 and CI$1,300 for the Cayman Islands as a whole. The Caymanian Journal (TCJ) reached out to Dilbert by email on 10 November 2026 to ask what her figures were drawn from.

Homes at CI$160,000, salaries near CI$3,000

Dilbert told the committee the corporation's three-bedroom homes "are being sold for $160,000" and that applicants must first obtain pre-approval from a bank. "For some that probably will not happen because the average salary in Cayman Brac will not fall in the $5,000 range," she said. "It is much below that. It's probably within the $3,000 range." She then put the question back to the committee: "And so, how do we make the homes affordable?"

The Auditor General's report records that the programme is open to single applicants earning up to CI$5,500 a month, or CI$66,000 a year, and joint applicants earning up to CI$8,000 a month, or CI$96,000 a year. Those figures are ceilings on who may apply and are not the income a bank requires. Dilbert said the applicants chosen for the four newest homes had obtained pre-approval and must now return to their banks for the mortgage itself, and that the first assessment "did not include all of those things like house insurance, life insurance, you know, all of the add-ons". For some, she said, "it could be very difficult for them to meet their financial obligations when it comes to a mortgage".

Asked whether she had made that analysis known to the minister, Dilbert said: "I don't want to speak out of line. So, I'm certain that he is aware." TCJ asked the Minister for District Administration and Home Affairs, Nickolas DaCosta MP, for comment by email on 10 November 2026, and his ministry said that it expected to provide a further update the following week.

Dilbert added that the board had looked at the Government's 10-year housing plan and at multi-unit designs, which would have to be single-storey because many applicants care for an elderly relative. Earlier architectural drawings were set aside, she said, because the Brac community wanted "to go back to the bungalow type home".

Three steps to land a load of materials

Dilbert said cost was "the driving factor" in building on the Brac. "We have to import everything and it's a three-step import," she told the committee. "It comes from the U.S. to Grand Cayman then to Cayman Brac." Freight charges are steep, she said, the island relies on the barge, large containers are difficult to bring in and most material arrives on a flat rack, which limits what can be carried.

The same costs have blunted the option of building on an applicant's own land. Dilbert said few took it up because "it is so costly to fill property in Cayman Brac", and that preparing the site for the four newest homes had itself been "quite costly". She said government projects on the Brac go through the same procurement portal as those in Grand Cayman, and that the criteria contractors must meet were one reason only two bid for the latest build.

What the Auditor General found

The Auditor General's report found that the SIAHDC built no homes between 2019 and 2024 despite spending CI$0.6 million, holding land for the purpose and having an agreed target of three homes a year. As at February 2026 it had 24 people on its waiting list, with an average wait of 2.5 years, and neither a board charter nor a documented strategic plan. Across George Town, West Bay and Bodden Town, the report found, average rents rose 42% between 2019 and 2024, from CI$1,366 to CI$1,945 a month. It put spending on affordable homeownership programmes across the Cayman Islands at nearly CI$68 million over the same period.

Dilbert, who was appointed chair from 1 September 2025 and told the committee she has been a director since August 2021, said the pandemic had interrupted the programme, the process restarted in 2023 and construction of four homes at The Highlands in Spot Bay began in 2025. Those homes have been allocated using a new 100-point scoring matrix that weighs housing need, income, connection to the Sister Islands, first-time buyer status, dependants and caregiving, disability or medical vulnerability and readiness for home ownership. The board charter has been drafted and is still targeted for adoption in the final quarter of 2026, she said, although the board is two directors short and has at times struggled to reach a quorum.

The corporation had no staff of its own in earlier years, Dilbert said. An administrative officer was assigned through the ministry in 2023 and a strategic policy adviser in October 2025, and she told the committee the board had since "made a lot of progress".

The corporation has funding to build two more homes in early 2027 on the two remaining Highlands parcels, Dilbert told the committee. Nine parcels at West End, four of which had planning permits previously, need clearing and filling first, and the board is in discussion with the Public Works Department about that work. A further site, The Woodlands, which she called the largest, must be subdivided before it can be used.

PAC chair Roy McTaggart MP thanked Dilbert for the candour of her evidence and said there was "definitely a change" taking place at the corporation. Dilbert closed by thanking the Auditor General "for pointing out those areas that we were falling short", and said: "We trust that the next time when the report comes out we will look good."

Published November 13, 2026, 11:32 PM

Join the discussion — please keep to our Community Guidelines.