The Editor speaks: I receive nothing, you receive thousands – for the same position

Archive
3 min read

Cayman Islands Auditor
General, Sue Winspear, has just released a report examining pay and
benefits to the boards of directors of 24 government companies and
statutory authorities.


Some
receive nothing and some receive thousands.


Do
the one's that receive nothing put in the same hours as the ones that
receive thousands?


That
was not disclosed.


Apart
from the ones that receive nothing the vast majority receive only
between $150-$200 a meeting for volunteering their services.


The
Cayman Islands Monetary Authority is a big standout as the chairman
(Wayne Panton) receives $4,000 a month, his Deputy $2,000 and each
board member $1,500 per month.


Even
bigger is OfReg. Linford Pierson is the current chairman, and he
receives $4,500 per month, his Deputy $2,500 and board members
$2,000.


The
next largest pay out drops significantly down to $562 per meeting for
the chairman of the Maritime Authority, Phillip Barnes, and $375 for
board members.


Philip
Rankine, the Cayman Airways chairman receives nothing as does his
other board members. Wait, though, before applauding. Rankine and
other board members receive free flights for themselves and THEIR
FAMILIES on all Cayman flights. During the 18-month budget period
under review, ending Dec. 31, 2017, the seven board members were
given a total of 416 airline tickets! The cost? $80,000!!

How many hours a month do all these persons actually put in to justify these sums? Do they meet every month or more, or less?

Apparently the roles and responsibilities of boards of directors are not the same. The norm seems to be attending regular meetings and setting broad policy goals. Some even get to hire and fire the CEO.


The
majority of all these persons have other jobs or are retired.


According
to the Aud Generals's Report, in the 18-month budget period, the 24
Statutory Authorities and Government Companies Board Members cost us
a total of $788,000!


Worse
still, OfReg that only operated EIGHT months during this eighteen
month period, paid out


$113,000
of that $788,000!!!

It was only a few month ago OfReg was asking for more money to operate.

Also included in the Report was the number of persons employed in these statutory authorities and government companies – 2,743. over the 18 month period the total payout was $249 million!


Can
you guess who has the largest number of employees? No prize if you
are right. It is the Health Services Authority. 851 persons. It also
had the highest average salary for key personnel at $13,434 a month.


All
of us who live here must be very healthy to justify all the above.


Whilst
I am on the subject of health, my least favorite government body
CINICO - Cayman Islands National Insurance Company pay out $5,384 per
month for regular workers (the persons who actually do the most
work), whilst the key personnel receive $12,473.


Winspear
says. “There is currently no standardised job evaluation system or
salary and allowances scale for SAGCs. The Public Authorities Law
intends to deliver a standardised pay system, but the implementation
date for this particular clause in the law has been pushed back to
June 2019.”


I
have no doubt it will get pushed back again. Even a year away is too
near for government to act.


But
they should. Our revenues we are receiving now will not go on
forever.


It
doesn't matter if I receive nothing for doing the same job as others.
Its the others that receive thousands that should be worried. Money
goes into a pot and it is not bottomless. It also shrinks in size.

Published February 7, 2019

Join the discussion — please keep to our Community Guidelines.