Before Cayman Fills Another Parcel, Someone Should Say Where the Water Goes

Like clockwork, we pull out the rain boots, say a prayer for our vehicles, prepare for the mosquitoes and allow extra time for traffic that was already moving slowly enough. Cayman’s rainy season brings a familiar set of adjustments, including the mental map of roads to avoid and the anxious glance outside to see whether the yard is holding water again.
We need the rain. After stretches of heat and dry ground, there is relief in hearing it fall. Then the relief becomes a calculation: which road will be flooded, how long the journey will take and whether the water will recede before the next downpour. For some households, the questions are more serious. Will it reach the door? What needs to be lifted? Can everyone get out to work or school?
The wet season generally runs from May through November, meaning Christmas preparations can begin while we are still dealing with the consequences of heavy rain. Along with the decorations comes the familiar public conversation about drainage: clear the drains, check the drains and put in more drains. Necessary work, certainly, but after years of watching familiar places disappear beneath standing water, I keep returning to the same question: where is the water supposed to go?
My memory of flooding promises stretches back to the days of multi-member constituencies, when the larger districts each elected several MLAs and election platforms offered plenty of opportunities to hear what would finally be fixed. Alongside healthcare, the cost of living and immigration, flooding was a dependable subject. I remember candidates promising relief for communities that knew exactly what the next rainy season would bring.
Since then, we have changed our electoral system, with 19 single-member constituencies in place since the 2017 General Election, expanded our road network and transformed enormous stretches of Grand Cayman. Yet residents in some familiar neighbourhoods are still watching the water rise. Windsor Park, Prospect and Randyke Gardens are among the places that come immediately to my mind. They are not an exhaustive list or a ranking of who has suffered most; people elsewhere will have their own roads, yards and experiences to add.
The familiarity is the point. Residents know where the water collects, which entrance becomes impassable and how long the clean-up will take. Their experience should help shape what happens next. When a community has lived with recurring flooding for years, its knowledge deserves a place in the decisions affecting its future.
There have been drainage works and improvements over the years. It would be unfair to dismiss the efforts of crews clearing blocked drains or engineers working within difficult conditions. But a drain needs somewhere to discharge, and a cleared opening cannot, by itself, answer every question about the land around it. Maintenance is essential; understanding the wider drainage system is equally important.
Grand Cayman’s geography makes this particularly challenging. We live on a low-lying limestone island, where rainfall, groundwater and the surrounding sea all influence drainage. There is limited elevation to work with, and large areas of wetland form part of the landscape. Engineering has to work with those conditions, including the limitations they impose.
What the land was already doing
The Central Mangrove Wetland is one of the island’s defining natural features. Places many of us grew up simply calling “swamp” have functions that become harder to overlook when the roads are underwater. The Department of Environment describes mangroves as natural sponges, trapping and slowly releasing surface water and helping counter the increased runoff associated with buildings and paved areas.
A parcel of land that looks empty to someone considering its development may therefore already be doing a job for the surrounding area. It may hold rainwater, allow it to soak into the ground or provide a route towards a larger wetland. Before that parcel is cleared, filled or built upon, we need to understand how changing it will affect the water and the people living nearby.
A new roof collects rain, a paved car park sheds it, and filling and raising a parcel of land changes its height relative to neighbouring properties. Roads, boundary walls and other structures can also alter the routes water takes. What happens within one property’s boundaries can have consequences beyond them, particularly where older homes sit on lower ground.
That is not just theory. In July 2025 the UK’s Joint Nature Conservation Committee published flood modelling of the South Sound basin, run with the Department of Environment, comparing the area as it stood in 2021 with the same area once approved and planned development is added. In the heavy-rainfall scenarios, water was pushed off newly raised parcels into the remaining mangroves and existing residential areas, in some places up to half a metre deeper, and into land outside the basin altogether. The authors note that the models have not yet been checked against measured flood levels and did not include existing drainage, but the direction of travel is plain.
This does not mean every development causes flooding or that every flooded neighbourhood has the same problem. It means drainage must be considered across the affected area, with attention to existing homes and the combined effects of development. If a parcel is raised, what happens to the lower property next door? If land that previously held water is filled, where will that water be accommodated? When several developments are approved separately, who examines what they will collectively mean for the surrounding community?
One site at a time
Part of this is already asked. Stormwater guidelines published by the National Roads Authority say applicants for major developments must show that their drainage can cope with two inches of rain an hour for an hour, and that lower surrounding properties and nearby public roads will not be subject to runoff from the site. That is a sensible test, and it speaks directly to the neighbour on lower ground. It is set site by site, however, and what many approvals add up to across a whole area is a different question.
Those questions should be answered while there is still an opportunity to change a design. By the time a resident is lifting furniture or trying to stop water entering a home, the consequences have become personal and expensive. That household needs help, but it also deserves an explanation of what happened and what can be done to reduce the likelihood of it happening again.
What the wells can and cannot do
We should be honest about the limitations of the systems we install. The National Roads Authority’s annual report for 2024 records that heavy rain coinciding with king tides made flooding significantly worse than usual that year, and that drain wells in Newlands, Prospect, South Sound and parts of West Bay were of much less effect because the water table was unusually high. The authority deployed nearly a dozen emergency pumps, and the same report puts its spending on new drain well installations across the island at about CI$400,000 for the year. That matters because it challenges the assumption that another well will always provide a complete solution.
Some places may need better maintenance, while others may require additional water storage, improved routes for water to move, protection of natural drainage areas or a combination of measures. Choosing the appropriate response requires evidence about the location. Residents should be able to understand that evidence and what the proposed work is expected to achieve.
If a measure can reduce flooding but cannot eliminate it, say so. If a project depends on land access, funding or further studies, explain that too. A list of drains cleared tells us work has been done, but it does not tell a family whether next year will be any different. They measure progress by how high the water rises, how long it remains, whether they can get home and whether it comes through the door.
We cannot reasonably demand that an island be immune to exceptional rainfall or severe storms. We can expect known problems to inform planning decisions, and we can ask for a clear account of progress. We should also expect improvements to be assessed across the surrounding area, so that relief for one location does not simply transfer the problem elsewhere.
Who carries the cost
The cost of getting this wrong falls into ordinary lives. It is the worker who loses hours, the parent collecting children through another traffic standstill and the family spending its weekend cleaning up again. Those costs deserve a place in the development conversation alongside the benefits of whatever is proposed. They are borne by people who may have had little say in the changes around them.
There is also a question of fairness when we consider what residents can realistically do to protect themselves. A homeowner may be advised to improve drainage or raise vulnerable areas, but those measures cost money and may require permissions, professional advice and space the property does not have. A tenant has even less control. People cannot simply lift an established home to match the height of whatever is being built around it.
Individuals still have a part to play. We can keep litter and garden waste away from drainage openings, report blockages and seek advice before altering levels or drainage routes on our own properties. But we cannot be expected to solve changes to water flow across an entire neighbourhood. Public advice about clearing debris is useful; it becomes frustrating when people follow it and still face the same problem, with no clear explanation of what lies beyond their control.
We also need to think about the information available to someone buying or renting a home. A viewing on a sunny afternoon tells you very little about how a road behaves after hours of rain. People should be encouraged to ask about previous flooding, drainage arrangements and any planned changes nearby. Reliable, accessible information about known flood-prone areas would help families make better decisions and understand the precautions a particular property may require.
None of this removes the need for individual judgement or makes every flooded property someone else’s fault. It recognises that drainage connects people who may never meet, through land they do not own and decisions they did not make. Planning should account for those connections before problems arise. Otherwise, the same residents will keep carrying the cost, regardless of how carefully they maintain their own yards and drains.
Cayman will continue to grow, and the decisions we make now will shape how existing communities experience that growth. Before another parcel is filled, another road is raised or another large surface is paved, someone should be able to explain what happens when the rain arrives and how neighbouring properties will be protected.
By the next rainy season, residents in repeatedly flooded areas should be able to point to more than another promise. They should know what has been investigated, what action is planned, who is responsible and when they can expect it. After so many rainy seasons spent discussing how to fix the flooding, we owe those communities an answer to the question at the heart of it: where is the water supposed to go?
Published November 16, 2026, 11:15 PM
Join the discussion — please keep to our Community Guidelines.