Government Surplus Shrinks by CI$110 Million in a Single Quarter

The Government's surplus fell by CI$109.9 million between July and September, its latest unaudited accounts show.
The Unaudited Quarterly Financial Report for the nine months to 30 September 2026, prepared by the Ministry of Finance and Economic Development and published in the Gazette on 6 November, puts the surplus for the entire public sector at CI$142.4 million. The Ministry's report for the six months to 30 June, published on 7 August, put the same figure at CI$252.3 million.
Over the same three months the Government's cash and deposits fell by CI$155.3 million, from CI$588.9 million to CI$433.7 million, while its debt stood at CI$468.2 million. "As at 30 September 2026, debt exceeds cash and deposits, a position expected to be temporary," the report said. The Ministry's 12 November press release announcing the report does not refer to the debt position.
The report said the surplus "is expected to reduce significantly" as planned operating and capital spending is carried out in the final quarter. Minister for Finance and Economic Development Rolston Anglin MP told Finance Committee on 8 October that the Ministry's August reforecast projects a full-year operating surplus of CI$26.6 million for 2026 and borrowing of CI$124.0 million, according to the Government's published account of that sitting. The approved 2026 Budget provided for a full-year core government surplus of CI$11.1 million.
"Unsustainable", says Public Accounts Committee chair
Roy McTaggart MP, Chair of the Public Accounts Committee and a former Minister of Finance, said in a written reply on behalf of the Opposition on 15 November that the Ministry's release had left out the most important change in the quarter. "The Ministry did not point out the very significant increase in the cash burn rate in the third quarter," he said. "The Statement of Cash Flows discloses that cash and cash equivalents declined by [CI]$155m in the 3rd quarter, of which [CI]$90.5m is attributed to Operating Activities. This is unsustainable."
The report's own comparison column shows total cash and deposits down CI$155.3 million in the quarter and net cash from operating activities at CI$181.3 million at 30 June against CI$90.5 million at 30 September, a third-quarter movement of CI$90.7 million.
Mr McTaggart said the pace of spending would force the Government to borrow before the year is out. "Based on the present cash burn rate, it is likely that the government will need to complete their 2026 borrowing program and draw down the loan prior to December 31, 2026, in order to maintain compliance with the Cash Reserves element of the Principles of Responsible Financial Management," he said.
The Government has set out the same timetable. Its request for proposals for a CI$236 million loan facility, issued on 29 September, provides for a first tranche of CI$124 million "upon signing of the agreement, or by 31 December 2026 at the latest", according to a Government release of 14 October. The release said the agreement was expected to be signed in December 2026 and that the borrowing is to fund the capital programme, not core government's operating expenditure.
He did not dispute the strength of revenue. "The Cayman economy and indeed government's coffers continue to perform at a robust level, with revenues continuing to exceed budget projections," he said, adding that the Government's revenue forecasts "have always been conservative", which had allowed it to return to Finance Committee for supplementary funding. "However, the level of spending continues to be of concern to the opposition." Asked whether the CI$26.6 million full-year forecast was credible, he said the Opposition believed the Government would achieve an operating surplus for the year, "however, it is anyone's guess whether the forecast of [CI]$26.6m is credible or not."
A seasonal fall, but a bigger one than last year
Part of the third-quarter decline is seasonal. Most financial services licence fees are due at the start of the calendar year, and the report said they "typically align favourably with the budget through to the Third quarter and then stabilise for the remainder of the year". Core government took CI$190.3 million in coercive revenue, meaning fees, duties and levies, in the July to September quarter, against CI$1.008 billion over the nine months. A year earlier the equivalent surplus fell from CI$201.5 million at 30 June 2025 to CI$137.4 million at 30 September 2025.
The decline continued into September. Mr Anglin told Finance Committee on 8 October that the core government surplus at 31 August was CI$175.3 million. The Gazetted figure for core government at 30 September is CI$134.3 million.
Core government spent CI$931.2 million in the nine months, CI$80.1 million more than in the same period of 2025, while revenue rose by CI$95.0 million to CI$1.065 billion.
Fund fees and record arrivals
The revenue that beat budget came from the financial services register and the airport. Mutual fund administrators' fees were CI$5.8 million over budget and private fund fees CI$3.5 million over, which the report attributes to more funds registered; against 2025 the two lines are up CI$9.5 million and CI$10.0 million. Exempt company fees came in CI$7.2 million above the CI$131.5 million budgeted, and securities investment business licences CI$3.6 million above. Tourist accommodation charges were CI$4.7 million over budget on what the report calls record-high visitor arrivals, with air arrivals up about 11% and cruise arrivals up 4% on the same period of 2025.
Investment income from cash held on fixed deposit added CI$17.4 million, CI$8.8 million over budget. Sales of goods and services brought in CI$40.1 million, CI$5.9 million over.
Five lines fell short. Gasoline and diesel duty was CI$5.3 million under budget, other import duty CI$5.6 million under, motor vehicle drivers' licences CI$5.7 million under, the special economic zone grant fee CI$5.1 million under and traders' licences CI$4.2 million under. In the third quarter alone, domestic levies on goods and services rose CI$11.4 million and levies on property CI$5.5 million against the same quarter of 2025, while import duties fell CI$9.4 million.
Health and welfare spending over budget
The biggest overspends are in healthcare and support payments. Payments to the Health Services Authority reached CI$61.3 million, CI$12.3 million over budget, with care of indigents CI$5.4 million over, geriatric services CI$4.4 million over and medical care for chronic ailments CI$1.7 million over. Tertiary care at local and overseas institutions cost CI$42.9 million, CI$10.7 million over budget.
Transfer payments of CI$86.6 million were CI$25.0 million over budget. Financial assistance cost CI$27.5 million, CI$9.5 million over budget. Scholarships and bursaries cost CI$31.3 million, CI$6.0 million over. Ex-gratia payments to seamen cost CI$11.3 million, CI$3.8 million over. Electrical assistance of CI$5.4 million was paid against no budgeted amount, and youth, sport, culture and heritage programmes cost CI$2.5 million, CI$2.2 million over. Against the first nine months of 2025, transfer payments rose by CI$7.4 million from CI$79.2 million.
Payments for outputs from statutory authorities and government companies as a whole reached CI$181.5 million, CI$13.5 million over budget and CI$27.6 million more than a year earlier. Outputs bought from non-governmental suppliers cost CI$64.6 million, CI$10.3 million over budget.
Finance Committee on 8 October then approved a further CI$44.9 million for 2026, including CI$17.5 million for tertiary medical care, CI$6.0 million for geriatric services, CI$9.5 million for financial assistance and CI$3.8 million for seafarers' and veterans' benefits, the Government said in its account of the sitting. Minister for Social Development and Innovation Isaac Rankine MP told the committee the financial assistance increase "relates mainly to the increased cost of rent, food and utilities". The Economics and Statistics Office reported on 20 November that the inflation rate was 5.7% for the second quarter of 2026. Minister for Health, Environment and Sustainability Katherine Ebanks-Wilks MP said of the health items: "These services are inherently episodic in nature and they're delivered based on specific, often urgent episodes of critical healthcare needs."
What is holding the surplus up
Unfilled jobs are the single largest saving. Personnel costs of CI$397.6 million were CI$29.2 million under budget, which the report attributes to "vacant posts across several Ministries, Portfolios and Offices". Supplies and consumables were CI$16.1 million under budget, mostly on professional fees and purchased services. Personnel costs were nonetheless CI$20.0 million higher than in the same period of 2025, and supplies and consumables CI$12.7 million higher. Purchase of services, mainly professional fees, cost CI$70.5 million against a budget of CI$82.8 million. The report cautioned that both savings "may not translate into full-year savings" and that personnel savings "may reduce as vacant posts are filled". Ministries, it said, expect costs to move closer to budget "as more projects come online".
On the revenue side, property is doing the work. Stamp duty on land transfers brought in CI$108.9 million, CI$38.3 million more than in the first nine months of 2025 and CI$20.6 million over budget. The report attributes the rise to several high-value developments, reassessment of properties to current market values and the new 10% stamp duty rate on most transactions above CI$2.0 million. Transaction volumes were up 26.1% on 2025, the total value of transactions up 48.2% and the average transaction value up 17.7%. Share transfer charges on land holding companies added CI$5.7 million, CI$5.1 million more than a year earlier, which the report links to rising values in what it calls the luxury and lifestyle property market.
The Government also gave some of that revenue back. It waived or refunded CI$10.3 million in the nine months, including CI$4.3 million on 210 waivers for first- and second-time Caymanian property buyers, CI$2.5 million on 73 stamp duty waivers granted at the Minister's discretion and CI$2.4 million on eight discretionary refunds. Gasoline and diesel duty brought in CI$4.1 million, CI$7.1 million less than in 2025 and CI$5.3 million under budget, which the report attributes mainly to the fuel duty waiver that began on 1 June and has been extended to 31 December 2026.
The report describes most of those waivers as statute-based, granted once the criteria in the law are met, and the rest as "based on judgement and discretion". Mr McTaggart said the Minister for Finance and Economic Development is the Commissioner for Stamp Duty with discretion to waive it, and that the amounts "do not appear to be manifestly excessive".
Cayman Airways and the Turtle Centre
Statutory authorities and government companies recorded a combined surplus of CI$8.1 million against a budgeted deficit of CI$3.4 million, but CI$10.0 million less than in the same period of 2025. Cayman Airways recorded a deficit of CI$16.0 million against a budgeted deficit of CI$12.2 million. The Cayman Turtle Conservation and Education Centre recorded a deficit of CI$7.7 million. The Water Authority recorded a deficit of CI$0.5 million against a budgeted surplus of CI$1.9 million. The report said not all authorities had submitted returns for the period, and that the better-than-budget result rested mainly on the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority, the Health Services Authority, the National Roads Authority and the Port Authority.
Core government put CI$27.8 million of equity into those bodies in the nine months, including CI$18.2 million into Cayman Airways, CI$4.8 million into the Turtle Centre and CI$4.0 million into the Port Authority.
Where the cash went
The Statement of Cash Flows explains the fall in bank balances. Over the nine months the Government paid CI$72.8 million for property, plant and equipment and put CI$27.8 million of equity into statutory authorities and companies, a capital outlay of CI$100.6 million. It repaid CI$39.9 million of debt principal and made CI$8.6 million of lease payments. Fixed deposits of CI$406.5 million matured and CI$348.8 million was placed anew, a net reduction of CI$57.7 million in money held on deposit.
The report notes a CI$7.6 million gap between capital cash actually spent and the CI$92.9 million of capital appropriations drawn down, which it describes as a timing difference.
Of the CI$468.2 million of debt, CI$43.0 million falls due within one year. The report said the balance "will decline with scheduled principal repayments being made", and that the Government continues to place surplus cash on fixed deposit because of the size of the balances on hand.
The Government's unfunded pension liability for the defined benefit part of public sector pension plans stood at CI$93.0 million as at 31 December 2025, the most recent valuation it gives, down from CI$156.1 million a year earlier.
Projects that have not started
The report's Capital Projects Tracker lists what the money is meant to buy. At 30 September several items in the Ministry of District Administration and Home Affairs showed no spending at all. Fire Service 1,000-gallon tankers (CI$1.2 million), the Border Control system upgrade (CI$1.45 million), biometrics for customs and border control (CI$1.8 million), the Northward waste water treatment plant (CI$1.0 million) and a computer-aided dispatch system (CI$1.0 million) were each recorded at 0% complete. The replacement ladder truck (CI$1.65 million) and the Cayman Brac bay extension and vehicle servicing pit (CI$1.7 million) were also at 0%.
Further along were the Weather Service headquarters at 90% complete with two months to go, the WORC system build-out at 80%, and the new prison design at 80%, with pre-construction work recorded as starting in the second quarter of 2026. The tracker gives operating costs once complete as "TBD" for every project listed.
The Ministry's position
The Ministry has said since July that the mid-year surplus was never the expected year-end result. When Finance Committee approved CI$134.3 million of supplementary spending on 30 June, the Government forecast a full-year operating surplus of about CI$10.5 million; by the August reforecast that figure had risen to CI$26.6 million. In a statement on 2 September, Mr Anglin said: "Capital investment expenditures reduce Government's bank account balances." He added: "It is equally important to distinguish between approval to spend and money actually spent." The Ministry had not responded to questions sent by email on 13 November by the time of publication.
The report records the Government as compliant with all six Principles of Responsible Financial Management under the Public Management and Finance Act (2026 Revision). Cash reserves covered 100.9 days of operating expenses against a minimum of 90. Net debt was 14.3% of core government revenue against a ceiling of 80%, and debt servicing was 6.4% of revenue against a ceiling of 10%.
The quarterly report is unaudited. It says it is drawn from the Government's financial management system and on "the representations and judgments" of the chief financial officers of ministries, portfolios, offices and authorities, and that the law requires it to be Gazetted within six weeks of the quarter's end.
The supplementary spending approved on 30 June and 8 October will go into a Supplementary Appropriation Bill, which the Act requires to be introduced in Parliament no later than 31 March 2027. The fuel duty waiver is due to end on 31 December. The fourth-quarter position, and whether the Government drew on its 2026 borrowing before the year closed, will be shown in the report for the year ended 31 December 2026.
Published November 21, 2026, 1:35 PM
Join the discussion — please keep to our Community Guidelines.