The Editor speaks: “Why did they take prayer out of the public schools?”

Archive
3 min read

That isn't me asking that question. It
is Rabbi Yisroel Goldstein, who was injured in the synagogue shooting
near San Diego, USA.

The U.S. Supreme Court in 1962 banned
school-sponsored prayer in public schools in a landmark decision,
saying it violated the First Amendment.

Similar legislation has been instigated
in many other countries, including the UK.

A 19-year-old gunman armed with an
assault-style weapon who wrote a manifesto of hate against Jewish
people, killed Lori Gilbert Kaye, 60, after shielding Goldstein from
the bullets. Three others were injured in the shooting, which
happened last Saturday, the final day of Passover.

Goldstein is quoted in the article we
ran yesterday ( May1) see-
http://www.ieyenews.com/wordpress/rabbi-in-us-synagogue-shooting-let-students-reflect-on-god/

“When Ronald Reagan was shot, a
campaign was launched that public schools should introduce a moment
of silence. I’m hoping to get legislation to reintroduce that, that
children when they start their day should take a moment of silence to
think about themselves and to realize that they are children of God,
that they have a soul, that they are created in the image of God, to
value life, and to value more of life than just the materialism, that
there’s a spiritual dimension to life.”

“This must stop, and I’m hoping
that the tragedy that happened at our congregation would be the
impetus to rethink what is the problem, why have we gone wrong,” he
added. “America was built on religious values. In God we trust. Our
founding fathers of America wanted our children to grow up with God
in their lives, with a spiritual life to them.”

Is he right?

He is wrong when he said the Supreme
Court banned school-sponsored prayer in public schools. They didn't.
However, they might just as well as done. Schools are forbidden from
initiating or sponsoring religious activities, including prayer, but
religious groups are permitted to meet on school grounds after
school, and students can pray to whatever or whomever they want at
any time of day, as long as they do it privately and don’t try to
force others to do the same.

It's like saying schools cannot
initiate learning subjects such as mathematics and history but
students can learn these on school grounds after school.

Actually, I blame the media. There has
been many, many articles (yes I have just looked) demeaning anyone
who tries to connect mass gun violence to the banning of compulsory
religion.

They can produce stats to prove their case. Since the ban on school sponsored prayer gun crime has gone down they shout. However, they ignore any stats that show very, very few (I haven't found one, but then I haven't got many, many hours to spare) crazed gun shooters habitually go to church and/or from practicing Christian homes! The ones that pray to God and teach their children to do the same!!

That is the point the Rabbi was making.
He is a Jew. So was Jesus Christ.

Published May 1, 2019

Join the discussion — please keep to our Community Guidelines.